June 23, 2024 by Mike Manazir – (4-5 minutes)
Blockbuster was a dominant player in the video rental industry during the 1990s and early 2000s. At its peak, Blockbuster had thousands of stores worldwide and was synonymous with movie rentals. Below, I share how Blockbuster continuing to ignore data over time, eventually led to the demise of the company.
Perils of Ignoring Data
Netflix Partnership Rejection in 2000: Reed Hastings, the co-founder of Netflix, approached Blockbuster with a proposal to partner where Netflix would handle Blockbuster’s online presence, and Blockbuster would promote Netflix in its stores. At the time, data indicated a growing trend in online rentals and the potential of a subscription-based model. Blockbuster dismissed the idea, failing to recognize the shift in consumer preferences towards online service. Netflix grew exponentially, capitalizing on the digital trend while Blockbuster continued to rely heavily on its physical store model.
Late Fee Policy: Data showed that customers were increasingly frustrated with Blockbuster’s late fees, which were a significant source of revenue but was also a major pain point. Instead of using this data to innovate and improve customer satisfaction, Blockbuster maintained its late fee policy for too long. Competitors like Netflix offered no late fees and a more customer-friendly subscription model, which attracted disgruntled Blockbuster customers.
Streaming Services Ignored: Data from the early 2000s indicated a growing trend towards digital streaming and on-demand services. Blockbuster was slow to develop its own streaming service. By the time it launched Blockbuster Online, Netflix and other competitors had already established strong footholds. Blockbuster’s late entry into the streaming market failed to gain needed traction.
Consequences: Blockbuster’s revenues declined sharply as customers migrated to more convenient alternatives like Netflix and Redbox. In 2010, Blockbuster filed for bankruptcy burdened by debt and unable to compete in the evolving market.
Analysis
Blockbuster’s failure to leverage data-driven insights and adapt to changing consumer behaviors was a critical factor in its downfall. The company’s reluctance to innovate and embrace digital transformation, despite clear data indicating market shifts, led to its ultimate demise.
Blockbuster serves as a powerful example of how ignoring data and failing to adapt to market trends can result in significant business losses and, ultimately, the collapse of an industry giant.
Any business can create a successful formula for data-driven decision-making using the steps below:
1. Define Objectives: For example, to increase online sales by 20% over the next year.
2. Data-Driven Culture: Train staff on data tools and the importance of data in driving sales.
3. Collect Data: Gather data from website analytics, sales records, customer feedback, and market research.
4. Tools and Technology: Implement a CRM system and use analytic frameworks such as Google Analytics for website data and Power BI for reporting.
5. Analyze Data: Analyze customer purchase patterns, website behavior, and market trends.
6. Make Decisions: Use insights to optimize the website, personalize marketing campaigns and adjust product offerings. This step is most important because it allows you to apply your human “wisdom” and act on the data.
7. Monitor and Adjust: Track sales metrics and customer responses, making adjustments as needed.
8. Governance: Ensure data is stored securely and customer data privacy is maintained.
Business leaders can leverage data to make informed decisions that drive success. As leaders, you must create a culture that is curious; values data using the right tools, and continuously learn and adjust your formula based on data insights and market trends.
In Michael Dell’s quote below there is power in intuition and gut feel. However, be sure to back up the “gut feel” with data. As you get more experienced, your gut feelings will actually be a result of what you are seeing and hearing in the marketplace. You’ll be subconsciously analyzing data as you live your day. Channeling John Boyd: “Observe, Orient, Decide, Act” [on the data].
“The data-driven culture is about empowering your people to make decisions based on data,
not just intuition or anecdote.“
-Michael Dell
Lead from your heart. Lead to Win.
Take Action
Mike’s Leadership Forum
- Do you have a comment or question to make on today’s blog?
- Do you have a leadership issue you would like us to process in a future blog?
- Do you need a speaker for an upcoming leadership event?
- Click CONTACT for comments.